First broadcast 7th February 1998.
Jonathan and Maddy investigate the mysterious disappearance of an El Greco painting from the home of theatre critic Sylvester Le Fley and his wife Lady Theresa Cutler.
Sam Bradley - Benjamin
Valerie Colgan - Martha
Bob Monkhouse - Sylvester Le Fley
Christine Kavanagh - Lady Theresa Cutler
Peter Copley - Eric
Alan Davies - Jonathan Creek
Stuart Milligan - Adam Klaus
Evie Garratt - Scooter Lady
Caroline Quentin - Maddy Magellan
Caroline Harris - Dr Irene Wolverton
John Hudson - Roy Gregson
Jemma Churchill - Second Therapist
Geoffrey McGivern - Barry Opper
Jocelyn Hughes - Judy
Sophie Langham - Melissa
Lucy Allen - Masseuse