First broadcast 7th March 2014.
A retired local psychic inadvertently makes the most amazing and impossible prediction of his career.
Alan Davies - Jonathan Creek
Sarah Alexander - Polly Creek
Marc Danbury - Burglar 1
Tim Faraday - Crispin Gilpin
James Bachman - Rev Hugh Chater
John Bird - Horace Greeley
Jarred Christmas - Warwick
David Gant - Eric Ipswich
Selina Griffiths - Alison Chater
John Walters - The Sandman
Chloe Buswell - Polly's Mother
Ella Purton - Young Polly
Adam Grayson - Young Eric Ipswich
John Voce - Captain Ian Amery-Cooper
Michael Troughton - Leonard Corbyn
Richard Banks - Man at 1960s fair
Mike Fordham - Polly's Father